17 Madison Street & 42 Church Street

A rare opportunity to own two separate homes situated on one lot in the heart of Sag Harbor Village, 17 Madison Street and 42 Church Street offer an exceptional combination of historic significance, timeless charm, and modern comfort. Together, these two distinct residences create a unique village compound, offering privacy, flexibility, and an extraordinary connection to Sag Harbor's rich history.

Completely renovated in 2020, 17 Madison Street serves as the principal residence, seamlessly blending classic architectural character with contemporary living. Warm and inviting, the home features beautifully proportioned rooms, multiple fireplaces, and a striking double-sided fireplace connecting the main living spaces. An eat-in kitchen opens directly to an outdoor patio, creating an effortless transition between indoor and outdoor entertaining. Multiple ensuite bedrooms provide comfortable accommodations, while the unfinished third floor offers exciting possibilities for additional living space.

The lower level presents potential for gallery or commercial use, adding another dimension to the property's versatility. Outside, plans and permits are in place for a 20' x 40' swimming pool, with additional space to accommodate a pool house, offering the opportunity to create a private outdoor retreat in the heart of the village.

The second, completely separate residence, 42 Church Street, is the historic Hand House, an extraordinary two-bedroom, two-bath home believed to be among the oldest surviving houses associated with Sag Harbor. Documented as standing before 1732, with origins possibly dating to the 17th century, the home is a remarkable example of early American architecture. Its post-and-beam construction, hand-hewn timbers, and traditional mortise-and-tenon joinery preserve the craftsmanship and authenticity of another era.

The Hand House has a fascinating history of its own. Originally located in Southampton, it was moved to Sagaponack in 1752, subsequently brought to Sag Harbor, and ultimately relocated to its present setting. The home was once owned by David Hand, a noted whaling captain, seaman, and soldier whose life became part of local legend. According to historical accounts, celebrated American novelist James Fenimore Cooper was so impressed by Hand that he drew inspiration from him in creating Natty Bumppo, the iconic protagonist of The Leatherstocking Tales.

With two independent homes sharing a single lot, this exceptional offering provides a level of flexibility rarely found in the center of Sag Harbor Village. The arrangement is ideally suited for extended family, visiting guests, or those seeking a separate residence for work or creative pursuits, while preserving the privacy and individuality of each home.

Just moments from Sag Harbor's celebrated restaurants, boutiques, galleries, and picturesque waterfront, 17 Madison Street and 42 Church Street represent a truly distinctive opportunity to own a beautifully renovated principal residence alongside an irreplaceable piece of American history.

Two separate houses. One remarkable property. A rare opportunity to own a piece of Sag Harbor's past while creating something extraordinary for the future.


17 Madison Street & 42 Church Street
17 Madison Street & 42 Church Street
17 Madison Street & 42 Church Street
17 Madison Street & 42 Church Street

Location